Login
Forgot Password?

OR

Login with Google Login with Twitter Login with Facebook
  • Join
  • Profiles
  • Groups
  • SuicideGirls
  • Photos
  • Videos
  • Shop
Vital Stats

madman31

Military Brat

Member Since 2005

Followers 28 Following 35

  • Everything
  • Photos
  • Video
  • Blogs
  • Groups
  • From Others

Sunday Apr 09, 2006

Apr 9, 2006
0
  • Facebook
  • Tweet
  • Email
In recent days, President Bush has come under some fire by scholars and pundits alike by saying that Iraq was NOT currently engaged in a civil war. But how do we know this? Factions within Iraq have been fighting against one another for months now.

Egypt President Hosni Mubarak, however, went on record by sayting that Iraq in fact WAS on the brink of civil war.

So this has gotten me thinking about what exactly encompasses civil war, and whether or not Iraq qualifies.

While the name itself is somewhat oxymoronic, a war is civil when (1) the warring factions are in the same country and (2) when those factions are vying for political control of that country. One of the things that separates a civil war from an internal war is that the objectives in a civil war are political. Internal wars deal with ethnic or religious differents that are not directly political.

There are a lot of other caveats that many scholars add. For example:

*The violence between factions must be prolonged

*The factions must be defined regionally

* The objects must be clear

But as the definition of war has changed in recent years, I think we can omit these extras, at least for now.

So let's go back to our original two criteria here. The factions involved are Sunni and Shiite muslims (as well as Kurds and a few smaller groups to a lesser extent), all of which operate within the confines of Iraq. So the differences between the groups are religious, which doesn't always qualify as being political. But in this case, it is about the future of Iraq and which religous group will have majority say in that future. So by my definition to this point, the war in Iraq is in fact civil.

At this time, I need to talk about insurgencies, because this is a word used to describe Iraq as well. An insurgency is an organized rebellion that engages in deliberate actions to cause the downfall of a governmental authority, through destruction and armed actions. Insurgents are in opposition to a civil authority or government primarily in order to overthrow or obtain a share in government, to further a separatist or revolutionary agenda, or improve their condition.

So are insurgencies civil wars? Most historians would tell you that insurgencies are civil only if they engage in conventional forms of warfare. By conventional, we mean uniformed troops, traditional military tactics, and the like. Clearly this is not happening in Iraq, and this is the justification president Bush uses for saying that Iraq is not in the midst of a civil war.

But I don't buy what the historians say. not any more. The days of the conventional war are waning. Operation Desert Storm was arguably one of its last gasps. Armies around the world, even the most advanced ones, are more and more using unconventional tactics, to the point where it is becoming the norm.

So the key to identifying civil wars is the objective, not the tactics. Are the objectives in Iraq political? Yes. Do said objectives invlolve a deligitimization of government? Certainly. Is a goal a changing of the government? More than likely yes.

What we have here is a civil insurgency--one that carries on the characteristics of both kinds of wars.

So Bush is half wrong and half right, which is about par for the course
VIEW 4 of 4 COMMENTS
gnarface_killah:
Hey I just Noticed in your Pics you went to Aruba

My best good friend is going. Any out of the way things he should keep his eyes out to see
Apr 9, 2006
kriss:
u so need to go hang in Asheville. IT is such a cool place.

kisses
KRISSwink
Apr 10, 2006

More Blogs

  • 06.05.07
    3

    Tuesday Jun 05, 2007

    The summer travel season is upon me, although it won't be quite as di…
  • 05.23.07
    6

    Wednesday May 23, 2007

    Wow! Where does the time go? The last three months arguably have be…
  • 02.21.07
    4

    Thursday Feb 22, 2007

    Holy shit...where does the time go? I must admit, all sorts of thing…
  • 01.21.07
    3

    Sunday Jan 21, 2007

    Had a lovely weekend...a couple of good friends from out of town drov…
  • 01.17.07
    7

    Wednesday Jan 17, 2007

    I admit it. I'm addicted to Google Earth. I can't stop searching …
  • 01.09.07
    5

    Tuesday Jan 09, 2007

    I'm still here, I promise. We're back from trips to Alabama and Te…
  • 12.20.06
    4

    Wednesday Dec 20, 2006

    I'm off to Alabama for the annual holiday visit with the in-laws. Ev…
  • 12.15.06
    9

    Friday Dec 15, 2006

    My first five days of Christmas vacation have been so-so. I've slept…
  • 12.15.06
    0

    Friday Dec 15, 2006

    My first five days of Christmas vacation have been so-so. I've slept…
  • 12.04.06
    9

    Monday Dec 04, 2006

    I'm a busy, busy boy, but the light is at the end of the tunnel. Yay…

We at SuicideGirls have been celebrating alternative pin-up girls for:

23
years
9
months
7
days
  • 5,509,826 fans
  • 41,393 fans
  • 10,327,617 followers
  • 4,593 SuicideGirls
  • 1,120,514 followers
  • 14,920,612 photos
  • 321,315 followers
  • 61,392,861 comments
  • Join
  • Profiles
  • Groups
  • Photos
  • Videos
  • Shop
  • Help
  • About
  • Press
  • LIVE

Legal/Tos | DMCA | Privacy Policy | 18 U.S.C. 2257 Record-Keeping Requirements Compliance Statement | Contact Us | Vendo Payment Support
©SuicideGirls 2001-2025

Press enter to search
Fast Hi-res

Click here to join & see it all...

Crop your photo