Login
Forgot Password?

OR

Login with Google Login with Twitter Login with Facebook
  • Join
  • Profiles
  • Groups
  • SuicideGirls
  • Photos
  • Videos
  • Shop
Vital Stats

reprobate

You can stand all night, at a red light anywhere in town.

Member Since 2002

Followers 166 Following 122

  • Everything
  • Photos
  • Video
  • Blogs
  • Groups
  • From Others

Sunday May 06, 2007

May 6, 2007
0
  • Facebook
  • Tweet
  • Email
Am I the only one who suspects that Vitamin Water is really just the exact same weak sugar water crap we all refused to drink in summer camp, but with a 600% markup?
VIEW 7 of 7 COMMENTS
mahogany:
Ok, here we go. I gotta keep this brief, but I think I can indicate my points for you to yell at some more.

>I think the discussion on the boards bears out, for the most part, that people, mostly childless men here, don't bother to avail themselves of the rudimentary facts, or even read the thread before spewing out their ill formed opinions.

I already addressed this in part over at the original thread. But my sense was that the original analysis was a bit confused, mixing up various underlying criticisms and not plotting any of them out. I don't think this helped folks who wrote replies. More on this when I engage what you are presuming to be BP's perspective below.

>As for a good scolding, if I wanted to do that, I would have pointed out that you completely missed the point of the article and its underlying philosophy, substituting instead a handful of flavor of the minute scholars who addressed the absolute reverse of the phenomena at play here.

My inclination to mention the flavor of the month can be explained as follows. Reading BitchPhD, both here and on her blog, she always seems to me to be about negotiating late academic trends, the line between second- and third-wave feminisms, and popular culture. When she does this well, it's a great read and interesting. Not unlike the old magazine Lingua Franca, but with feminist leanings. (Katha Pollitt does a great job of this task on a regular basis.)

But please note the slippage in the original article between what is being done and what BitchPhD fears it will set the precedent for. The citation of the Holocaust seemed an evocation of Agamben, as he is most well-known in popularized form for his theorizations of politics and the State through thinking through the concentration camp. Then again, as you no doubt know, Agamben does not exactly endorse Foucault's notion of bio-power, which also seemed to be at play in BitchPhD's argument about medicine and re-thinking women's pregnant bodies. Of course, neither of these lines were developed, nor were any others. In part, I think it's because they're not a great fit and she'd have to stretch them pretty far for it to make any sense. Hence, her imaginary fears, which fit the theorists I note better--which is why I think she interjected those specters. But that, again, is guesswork. It's hard to tell from the scant analysis in the piece.

I think that her final point, however, regarding the slippery slope misses the point entirely of racial, gendered and class exclusions, and it's a mistake that none of the people we've mentioned would have made. That's what bothered me. And led to my suggestion that looking at the history of how the rhetoric of child endangerment might have helped as it well demonstrates the racialized, gendered and classed policing of behavior. (The first suggestion, which was the closest to how I see the matter was Tilly's work, as you're right that Foucault and Agamben fit poorly.)

>This has nothing to do with a sovereign jurdically excepting themselves from the law they impose, or the technology of power and control, but rather garden variety propaganda coupled with the exception of otherness. The government assumes no special extra legal power here, and they employ a 600 year old technology whose application to dominate social thought was perfected centuries before Foucault was a dirty thought (or had one).

Yeah, see above.

>The critical deconstructive analysis of the mechanism at play here, is, in the philosophical realm, pure existentialism, although in the legal (constructive) arena its tools were well understood and examined two centuries before. But it wouldn't have been any fun to cite Sartre or Beauvoir, because people have actually heard of them, would it? Hell, if you were going to mis-apply a post structuralist, you'd have been better off with Lacan. At least there you could have claimed that this was globalizing the ego and assigning its taxonomy to marginalize.

>See, I went to college, too, I just did it before fashion came to dominate over critical thought.

I guess I'd be somewhat surprised if folks are reading Sartre or Beauvoir (more than, say, Foucault), and I'd be surprised if they were what BP had on her mind. I guess you're just ignoring my point that the comment I left was meant as a note to BP and NOT as either a full analysis in and of itself or a show for the crowds. My point was more a meta-point about how the BitchPhD columns have come to function on the site as a space for pointless culture wars and how BitchPhD's work can play into that deleterious trend. In essence I was trying to prod her to be more like her best work.

Now I'm really wondering who's wagging what, though, I must say. Let's just deflate a little, huh?
May 29, 2007
remusisdying:
sorry, i was just hoping you would be more specific regarding this 'overwhelming' evidence. im just curious, as i feel quite comfortable with the literature, and was surprised by your statement, as i feel we have different views of it. so "eh?" should have been "what about this evidence, specifically, makes you view it as support for an 'overwhelming' answer with regard to the effects of maternal alcohol consumption during the third trimester?" my apologies.
May 30, 2007

More Blogs

  • 08.28.07
    28

    Tuesday Aug 28, 2007

    Apparently, this is the summer I get to see all my friends naked. I'…
  • 08.05.07
    2

    Sunday Aug 05, 2007

    This is what you're all getting for Christmas. I hope it's your si…
  • 07.10.07
    5

    Tuesday Jul 10, 2007

    Its a great day for schadenfreude.
  • 07.02.07
    3

    Monday Jul 02, 2007

    Ever see a bar fight between a monkey and a chihuahua? Its not that …
  • 06.05.07
    1

    Wednesday Jun 06, 2007

    Yes, I'm feeling confrontational.
  • 05.06.07
    7

    Sunday May 06, 2007

    Am I the only one who suspects that Vitamin Water is really just the …
  • 04.30.07
    2

    Tuesday May 01, 2007

    So, we've got all these nifty new site features, which are great and …
  • 04.27.07
    2

    Friday Apr 27, 2007

    New Orleans Quiz Q; What do you do when you walk into a convenien…
  • 04.10.07
    1

    Tuesday Apr 10, 2007

    I need a new catch phrase. I'm torn between "Everything you love for…
  • 03.24.07
    3

    Saturday Mar 24, 2007

    Some days you're Mr. Hot Shit, some days you have to chop your chain…

We at SuicideGirls have been celebrating alternative pin-up girls for:

23
years
8
months
25
days
  • 5,509,826 fans
  • 41,393 fans
  • 10,327,617 followers
  • 4,593 SuicideGirls
  • 1,123,049 followers
  • 14,912,246 photos
  • 321,315 followers
  • 61,371,591 comments
  • Join
  • Profiles
  • Groups
  • Photos
  • Videos
  • Shop
  • Help
  • About
  • Press
  • LIVE

Legal/Tos | DMCA | Privacy Policy | 18 U.S.C. 2257 Record-Keeping Requirements Compliance Statement | Contact Us | Vendo Payment Support
©SuicideGirls 2001-2025

Press enter to search
Fast Hi-res

Click here to join & see it all...

Crop your photo