Login
Forgot Password?

OR

Login with Google Login with Twitter Login with Facebook
  • Join
  • Profiles
  • Groups
  • SuicideGirls
  • Photos
  • Videos
  • Shop
Vital Stats

liathach

Sheffield

Member Since 2008

Followers 37 Following 35

  • Everything
  • Photos
  • Video
  • Blogs
  • Groups
  • From Others

Friday Oct 30, 2009

Oct 29, 2009
0
  • Facebook
  • Tweet
  • Email
I'm reading Sister Helen Prejean's The Death of Innocents at present. Every page of this book shocks you to the core. How innocent men can be executed, trapped in a legal maze of pro-death rhetoric and political opportunism, that at times resembles Kafka's The Trial. Appeals turned down because of one wrongly typed word. DNA evidence rejected without examination. Witnesses disappeared, snitches recruited, juries manipulated. Evidence witheld from defence attorneys. After a while, it leaves you numb.

Of course, it's easy to oppose the death penalty when it comes to the wrongly convicted. Nobody wants to see an innocent person die. But I've opposed the whole concept of the death penalty for....well, my whole life it seems. I find it a morally repulsive solution to the problem of protecting society; the reason prosecutors usually give to jurors to persuade them to send someone to their death.

I have a whole host of reasons why I oppose it. But it all started with my Father. We have been diametrically opposed on political issues all my adult life. He is very much a conservative, so my socialism has always rubbed along rather poorly with his stance on various issues. But he has always opposed capital punishment as an acceptable judicial solution, and I inherited my opposition from him.

As I said, I have a host of reasons; most of which you could find in any book (the careerism of attorneys and judges tied to their pro-death stance is a potent one). But the one that seems most personal is that I believe when we execute someone we admit to our own failure. We have decided that, as a society, we are not capable of either rehabilitating that individual, or at least managing their lives so that both society and themselves are protected from their actions. We have been posed a complex question, and all we can offer is a simple answer. We are Pilate, washing our hands and walking away.

One additional argument that Prejean presents, that I have not come across before, is that, in order to support the death penalty, a country's citizens must give their government the right to kill them when it so chooses. I won't expand on that; just mull the implications over.

I don't have Prejean's faith. But I do share her belief in the UN Charter on Human Rights, that states that all human life is inviolable, and all humans, no matter how evil their deeds, have rights purely because they are human. A wry smile crossed my face when she mentioned that, in all the pro-life rhetoric the Catholic church is wont to indulge in (abortion, euthanasia, etc), the one pro-life issue they fudge is that of condemned criminals.

I'm lucky. I live in a country that does not execute its citizens. And the only debates we now have about extreme crimes is whether a life sentence should mean exactly that. Legal homicide (the cause of death cited on death certificates) is no longer an issue here. One of the key cases that decided it was of two youths, one armed, who were confronted by a police officer. When the officer asked the younger man to hand over the gun, the older youth shouted 'Let him have it!'. And the boy shot the officer dead. He was too young to be sentenced to hang. But the older youth wasn't. And on the basis of his shout, he was hung. But can anyone say what that call really meant?
VIEW 6 of 6 COMMENTS
wsoxfan:
I'm very pleased to be a part of this discussion with such intelligent and eloquent people.
Oct 30, 2009
kmk:
now, where is that dinning room table and dishes for me to do, hee hee! kiss. kmk!
Nov 1, 2009

More Blogs

  • 11.03.09
    6

    Wednesday Nov 04, 2009

    ...and kiss me. I've quit smoking... I'm glad you liked the Hallowe…
  • 10.29.09
    6

    Friday Oct 30, 2009

    I'm reading Sister Helen Prejean's The Death of Innocents at present.…
  • 10.27.09
    5

    Tuesday Oct 27, 2009

    Read More
  • 10.25.09
    4

    Monday Oct 26, 2009

    Read More
  • 10.22.09
    3

    Friday Oct 23, 2009

    'Click and read on' time! This was the first single I ever bought, be…
  • 10.20.09
    6

    Wednesday Oct 21, 2009

    Okay, we have a game today! Please click and continue reading... …
  • 10.18.09
    4

    Monday Oct 19, 2009

    I guess it's about time I told you all about my criminal conviction f…
  • 10.16.09
    2

    Saturday Oct 17, 2009

    My Saturday mornings are going downhill, and it's all my daughter's f…
  • 10.14.09
    7

    Thursday Oct 15, 2009

    Everyone who subscribes to SG stares at strangers. We look into the e…
  • 10.12.09
    4

    Tuesday Oct 13, 2009

    Read More

We at SuicideGirls have been celebrating alternative pin-up girls for:

23
years
9
months
10
days
  • 5,509,826 fans
  • 41,393 fans
  • 10,327,617 followers
  • 4,593 SuicideGirls
  • 1,120,443 followers
  • 14,921,484 photos
  • 321,315 followers
  • 61,395,321 comments
  • Join
  • Profiles
  • Groups
  • Photos
  • Videos
  • Shop
  • Help
  • About
  • Press
  • LIVE

Legal/Tos | DMCA | Privacy Policy | 18 U.S.C. 2257 Record-Keeping Requirements Compliance Statement | Contact Us | Vendo Payment Support
©SuicideGirls 2001-2025

Press enter to search
Fast Hi-res

Click here to join & see it all...

Crop your photo