Login
Forgot Password?

OR

Login with Google Login with Twitter Login with Facebook
  • Join
  • Profiles
  • Groups
  • SuicideGirls
  • Photos
  • Videos
  • Shop
Vital Stats

accuser

Member Since 2006

Followers 75 Following 78

  • Everything
  • Photos
  • Video
  • Blogs
  • Groups
  • From Others

Saturday Feb 20, 2010

Feb 20, 2010
0
  • Facebook
  • Tweet
  • Email
Saw Shutter Island.

WARNED BE YE: BELOW THAR BE SPOILERS

SPOILERS! (Click to view)
So even though I warned you, I'm not here to specifically discuss what happens at the end.

Instead, I wanted to talk about something this movie made me think of: the art of the twist. Knowing this flick has a twist is just about enough to spoil it for you. It did for me at about 20 minutes in.

I think there are two keys to having a successful twist in a story:
1) Don't lie to your audience to try to convince them there's no twist.
2) Don't lower the stakes with your reveal.

You could argue about the first point with this movie. The second, though, it pretty clearly broke. We go from a far-reaching conspiracy involving Machurian Candidate-type experiments and potentially hundreds of lives intertwined with a war story, to one dude's fevered delusion. The whole movie up to this point was, basically, a dream. Now, instead of the more significant story, we're helping a single crazy guy deal with his problems. And if he doesn't, well, that sucks. And if he does, well, that's good. I guess.

Fight Club is generally considered to have a successful twist, I think, because when we get the big reveal, everything still matters. No scene is invalidated - only shown under a new perspective. And all of the events surrounding the twist are still happening. Buildings are still blowing up. If anything, the stakes are higher because now this is all on the main character's head instead of Tyler Durden's.

The Sixth Sense also has a pretty good twist for the same reasons. Shyamalamadingdong's later movie, The Village, falls into at least one of the traps I described above. First we're hearing a mystery story about the strange traditions this village practices to protect themselves from the clearly supernatural, occult forces that surround them. Lives, possibly souls, are at stake. But it turns out they're actually just Amish. All of the tension from earlier in the movie is false, because there was no real danger, and the stakes are, again, lowered. No lives are at stake. There is nothing supernatural going on.

I know it seems like an awfully subjective measurement, and maybe you could argue the opposite position for each of these movies, but right now it seems to make sense to me. Seems like it'd be a good rule of thumb for film makers and writers to keep in mind, anyway.

VIEW 3 of 3 COMMENTS
bratpanties:
Haha, maybe! tongue

I can't read the spoiler because I haven't seen the movie yet, but would you recommend it?
Feb 20, 2010
fragilesong_:
Did you like it? I haven't seen it yet and I won't read the spoilers to find out!
Feb 24, 2010

More Blogs

  • 01.22.13
    3

    Tuesday Jan 22, 2013

    Once upon a time, there was a zone called the Barrens. Everyone went …
  • 12.12.12
    2

    Wednesday Dec 12, 2012

    I can't stop throwing money at Blizzard. I realm-transferred my Tr…
  • 10.29.12
    3

    Tuesday Oct 30, 2012

    Here's a thing you can make that's easy, not very expensive, lasts a …
  • 09.30.12
    8

    Sunday Sep 30, 2012

    I wrote this today: I dont care what anyone believes, as they long …
  • 09.29.12
    0

    Saturday Sep 29, 2012

    Remember when I used to blog about interesting things? No? Hey, fu…
  • 09.25.12
    0

    Tuesday Sep 25, 2012

    I'm reading the Prince Of Nothing series by R. Scott Bakker. I'm abo…
  • 09.12.12
    0

    Thursday Sep 13, 2012

    If you used to play WoW and you wanted to check out the latest change…
  • 08.21.12
    6

    Wednesday Aug 22, 2012

    Thank you, SG, for making me feel like I'm comparatively not that awk…
  • 08.02.12
    5

    Thursday Aug 02, 2012

    Alright, I made this up and I'm far too impressed with my own clevern…
  • 07.29.12
    2

    Sunday Jul 29, 2012

    I enjoy this way too much. Make sure you watch 1:29

We at SuicideGirls have been celebrating alternative pin-up girls for:

23
years
8
months
25
days
  • 5,509,826 fans
  • 41,393 fans
  • 10,327,617 followers
  • 4,593 SuicideGirls
  • 1,123,049 followers
  • 14,912,246 photos
  • 321,315 followers
  • 61,371,591 comments
  • Join
  • Profiles
  • Groups
  • Photos
  • Videos
  • Shop
  • Help
  • About
  • Press
  • LIVE

Legal/Tos | DMCA | Privacy Policy | 18 U.S.C. 2257 Record-Keeping Requirements Compliance Statement | Contact Us | Vendo Payment Support
©SuicideGirls 2001-2025

Press enter to search
Fast Hi-res

Click here to join & see it all...

Crop your photo