This one is a bit of a puzzler. I've seen really good reactions to it, really bad reactions to it, and absolute indifference. I suppose that's better than the polarized nature of the "Others arc", which seems to be greatly appreciated or greatly despised. I think my own reaction was somewhat muted. I liked it, it was fun, but it wasn't nearly as good for me as, say, "Flashes Before Your Eyes" or "The Cost of Living". At least it was more entertaining than the previous episode!

Here's my review for Lost 3.10: "Tricia Tanaka is Dead":

http://www.entil2001.com/series/lost/season3/lost3-10.html

Overall, this episode took on one of the central philosophical ideas at the heart of "Lost" and explored it in an unusual manner. This was definitely the most light-hearted episode of the season to date, and it's hard to imagine that anything could top it. There are some minor nitpicks along the way, and the episode could feel a bit like filler, but it's a fine addition to the third season.

This one is a bit of a puzzler. I've seen really good reactions to it, really bad reactions to it, and absolute indifference. I suppose that's better than the polarized nature of the "Others arc", which seems to be greatly appreciated or greatly despised. I think my own reaction was somewhat muted. I liked it, it was fun, but it wasn't nearly as good for me as, say, "Flashes Before Your Eyes" or "The Cost of Living". At least it was more entertaining than the previous episode!

Here's my review for Lost 3.10: "Tricia Tanaka is Dead":

http://www.entil2001.com/series/lost/season3/lost3-10.html

Overall, this episode took on one of the central philosophical ideas at the heart of "Lost" and explored it in an unusual manner. This was definitely the most light-hearted episode of the season to date, and it's hard to imagine that anything could top it. There are some minor nitpicks along the way, and the episode could feel a bit like filler, but it's a fine addition to the third season.